Stationery stores in New York City
“Best stationery store in New York?”
8 answers from 8 people · Updated Nov 2, 2026
A classic NYC stationery shop, from the owners of McNally Jackson bookshop, with three locations in Manhattan. Their wall of pens in jars is what my dreams are made of.
2
“You can delete an email, but you can burn a letter (TM)” Where else can you get letterpress stationery w a hot pink NYC pigeon hanging out alongside your name
Mr. Boddington’s Stationery Shop, Park Slope, Brooklyn
Truly magical stationery shop — a very-much-worth-it destination! Next door to Community Bookstore in Park Slope
20
Casey’s Rubber Stamp shop in the East Village
Inspiring me to send more snail mail, and stamp my stationary
41
Champion Stamp - One of a kind Stamp Store
Another beloved NYC gem for all the philatelists out there. Add to your itinerary! I still have a giant bag of vintage stamps from my days living in the city!
152
Brooklyn-based Sesame Letterpress offers beautiful papers made with iron letterpresses from the 19th century. I’ve ordered my stationery from them for years!
4
An extremely old-school, beautiful stationery shop in Oyster Bay (you can walk from the LIRR station), they also have NYC appointments weekly. The quality and craftsmanship is stunning. They can make anything you'd like!
12
