Angora rabbit hair, cashmere, and wool are so much warmer than polyester blend sweaters, it’s actually crazy. And you can find a ton of second hand options that are under $100 or even under $50 on Poshmark. Just make sure they have a picture of the tag so you can see the contents. I like cashmere / wool blends, wool / cotton for chunkier knits, and cashmere / silk / merino wool for lighter options. 100 percent wool is very warm but not as soft as the blends I mentioned. Alpaca wool and Angora rabbit hair sweater are both super soft and insanely warm.
Since it’s secondhand, read the description and check the photos carefully to make sure there are no holes or stains, and that the sweater hasn’t been warped or shrunk. Sometimes people include the laying flat measurements of the sweater, and you can always add a comment asking for these if they haven’t.
I’ve had great luck on there though! If you want to buy something new, I’ve had good luck with Quince’s cashmere and cashmere from Anthropologie. Cashmere quality can vary a lot though, so if it’s new and under $100, I would be very suspicious (which is why I prefer to shop more expensive brands but secondhand). more