Mystery Show

“When the aliens come and ask what podcasts are, we should give them the criminally short-lived 2015 treasure that is Mystery Show. It’s the best one.”

“I loved Mystery Show before I loved Heavyweight. They share a similar premise: uncovering something from the past, making sense of something that has nagged at someone. It only had one season, and still, 11 years later, the loss of it nags at me.”

“This is the perfect podcast. Each episode is brilliant! I truly can’t believe it was cancelled after one season. Do yourself a favor and listen to these mysteries. 🥲”

“Utterly delightful! Tragically only six episodes.”

“This show only ran for one season, but it was like catching lightning in a bottle. Beautiful.”

“Still can’t believe this left us so soon. A gem of a show.”

“two words: belt buckle”

“The greatest (+ shortest) podcast created.”