Mystery Show

Recommended by Noelle

in response to Sarah

What are your favorite podcast series? V long road trip ahead + would love some good, juicy, binge-worthy options to stay entertained.

Visit

Utterly delightful! Tragically only six episodes.

4 months ago

Comments

@tdubsJun 27, 2026

I still think about Mystery Show all the time

Noelle

@noelleJun 27, 2026

It was a perfect podcast. I so wish she would do more.

Across Rec League

Mystery Show

Mia

“I loved Mystery Show before I loved Heavyweight. They share a similar premise: uncovering something from the past, making sense of something that has nagged at someone. It only had one season, and still, 11 years later, the loss of it nags at me.”

134

Amy

“This is the perfect podcast. Each episode is brilliant! I truly can’t believe it was cancelled after one season. Do yourself a favor and listen to these mysteries. 🥲”