Rec League

Gimlet Media

Reply All: #158 The Case of the Missing Hit

Reply All: #158 The Case of the Missing Hit

A legendary episode of the Reply All podcast where host PJ Vogt tries to track down a pop song that exists only in one man's memory.

3 people recommend this

Recommended by

  • Lyla
    LylaFirst to rec

    “Who remembers this unbelievable podcast episode about a completely untraceable song that got stuck in a random man’s head. They DO END UP FINDING THE SONG BUT THE THINGS THEY DO TO GET THERE ARE CRAZY. JUST TRUST ME.”

    6985
  • Morgan
    Morgan

    “Reply All was truly the most interesting podcast of all time. Since ended but the whole catalog is full of bangers. PJ has Search Engine but it’s not the same 😢”

    162
  • Mia
    Mia

    “The most captivating podcast episode I’ve ever listened to. Ever. Of all time. Will never know anything better. Best of all.”

Related

Reply All

Reply All

14
Mystery Show: Case #3 Belt Buckle

Mystery Show: Case #3 Belt Buckle

176
StraightioLab: School (feat. Jo Firestone)

StraightioLab: School (feat. Jo Firestone)

2
Binchtopia: Honey, I Monetized the Kids

Binchtopia: Honey, I Monetized the Kids

102
Pablo Torre Finds Out: The Clippers

Pablo Torre Finds Out: The Clippers

11
NPR Music Podcast

NPR Music Podcast

Heavyweight

Heavyweight

363
Every Outfit

Every Outfit

1
Mystery Show

Mystery Show

4211
The Living Room (Love + Radio)

The Living Room (Love + Radio)

282
The Missing Cryptoqueen

The Missing Cryptoqueen

The Fall

The Fall

3
ExploreJournalSitemapAboutDevelopersTermsPrivacySupport

© 2026 Lyric Technologies, Inc.