Rec League

NYT Cooking

The Best Tomato Sandwich Recipe

The Best Tomato Sandwich Recipe

A popular recipe from NYT Cooking that elevates the classic tomato sandwich with heirloom tomatoes, mayonnaise, and toasted bread.

1 person recommends this

Recommended by

  • Nicole
    NicoleFirst to rec

    “I could cry thinking about how good this is, especially with some fresh heirloom tomatoes!! You don’t typically need a recipe for tomato sandwiches, but you do need this one.”

    33

Related

Tomato Salad Recipe

Tomato Salad Recipe

1
Tomato-Cheddar Toasts Recipe

Tomato-Cheddar Toasts Recipe

251
Tomato Toast Recipe

Tomato Toast Recipe

1255
Eggplant Parmesan Recipe

Eggplant Parmesan Recipe

1
Tuna and Tomato Salad Recipe

Tuna and Tomato Salad Recipe

4
Garden BLT Recipe

Garden BLT Recipe

183
The Perfect Tomato Sandwich Recipe

The Perfect Tomato Sandwich Recipe

1687
Seared Zucchini and Halloumi in Red-Wine Vinaigrette Recipe

Seared Zucchini and Halloumi in Red-Wine Vinaigrette Recipe

Turkey and the Wolf's Tomato Sandwich Recipe

Turkey and the Wolf's Tomato Sandwich Recipe

262
A Spin on PB and Pickles Recipe

A Spin on PB and Pickles Recipe

135
Tomatoes Dressed in Toasted Fennel and Anchovy Recipe

Tomatoes Dressed in Toasted Fennel and Anchovy Recipe

7
Fresh Tomato and Fennel Pasta Recipe

Fresh Tomato and Fennel Pasta Recipe

10
ExploreJournalSitemapAboutDevelopersTermsPrivacySupport

© 2026 Lyric Technologies, Inc.