Rec League

BBC Food

Apple Pie with Custard Recipe

Apple Pie with Custard Recipe

A classic double-crust apple pie made with three varieties of apples and served with a rich stovetop custard.

1 person recommends this

Visit

Recommended by

  • Tim Sondrup
    Tim SondrupFirst to rec

    “There's a scene in Practical Magic 2 where Ian pours warm custard over apple pie for Sally, and it stuck with me more than it probably should have. Not ice cream, not whipped cream, just custard poured slow right at the table. So I went looking for the real version of that, and found this one from BBC Food. It's a proper double crust pie with three kinds of apples, paired with a stovetop custard made from milk, cream, and vanilla, poured over the slice while it's still warm. Slower than a normal pie night, but worth it if you want that exact scene on your plate.”

    51

Related

Apple Pie Recipe

Apple Pie Recipe

3
Skillet Caramel-Apple Crisp Recipe

Skillet Caramel-Apple Crisp Recipe

10
Apple Crumb Pie Recipe

Apple Crumb Pie Recipe

192
Practical Magic

Practical Magic

14611
Baked Apples Recipe

Baked Apples Recipe

3
King Arthur's Dutch Apple Pie Recipe

King Arthur's Dutch Apple Pie Recipe

Practical Magic Movie Night Dinner Menu

Practical Magic Movie Night Dinner Menu

14
Sticky Apple Cake Recipe

Sticky Apple Cake Recipe

4
Four & Twenty Blackbirds Pie Crust Recipe

Four & Twenty Blackbirds Pie Crust Recipe

4
It's an Apple Tart, It's an Apple Galette Recipe

It's an Apple Tart, It's an Apple Galette Recipe

27
Squash and Caramelized Onion Tart Recipe

Squash and Caramelized Onion Tart Recipe

251
NYT Cooking

NYT Cooking

874
ExploreJournalQ&ASitemapAboutDevelopersTermsPrivacySupportReport content

© 2026 Lyric Technologies, Inc.