Go do this. My dad’s s ex-girlfriend who I insisted on staying with a part of each summer when I visited as a kid lived around the corner from the OG and this new iteration is very worth it.
Tuna melt is the jam!
2 months ago
Sign up to leave a comment.
Across Rec League


Phoebe
“S&P is a classic New York City luncheonette from the Court Street Grocers team, housed in the former Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop and retaining much of its original character. The menu is exactly what you’d hope to find in a place like this: pancakes, tuna melts, grilled cheeses, patty melts, and other staples. It’s fabulous.”

Jackie Mayol
“this is my fav restaurant and this is the perfect lunch order: tuna melt, side of pastrami, hand mixed diet coke no fkn notes. honestly everything here is good tho. I also love the pancakes and I’m desperately trying to have a banana split here soon.”

Chanteclair
“Went here all winter :)”





By submitting, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy