Amanda Hesser

Fantzye Bagels

Recommended by Amanda Hesser
View map
Visit

Fermented bagels for the win!

A Guide to the Hudson Valley

6 months ago

Comments

Sign up to leave a comment.

Across Rec League

Fantzye Bagels

Fantzye Bagels
will

will

“this is not your classic bagel shop and, for once, that’s a good thing. All the classics are really good but when you take their lead and order one of the special bagels off the menu, that is where they really shine.”

5
Paige Stewart Enslow

Paige Stewart Enslow

“sourdough bagels that go fucking crazy. get rosemary salt bagel with roasted leek schmear and don’t forget the chocolate chip cookie.”

1
Lizzie Noonan

Lizzie Noonan

“crazy delicious sourdough bagels with inventive combinations. i love the remix - folded egg w/ melted gouda, aioli and "secret green sauce" - or the veggie delight, which is essentially a salad bagel in the best way”

1
See 1 more

More like this

The Floral Society

The Floral Society

Moto Coffee/Machine

Moto Coffee/Machine

Lange Salt Co.

Lange Salt Co.

Freaks' NY

Freaks' NY

Follow Amanda Hesser

By submitting, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy

R
L
Share your recommendations on Rec League

© 2026PrivacyTerms