Teddie peanut butter

Recommended by Vickie

This is the best peanut butter. I’ve tried A LOT of natural peanut butter brands, including the fancy niche ones, but Teddie reigns supreme. Perfectly salted, great flavor, and somehow does not separate too much even with no added oils. Also very affordable and easy to find!!

In my pantry/fridge

2 months ago

Comments

Carly

@carlycAug 17, 2026

agreed!! the absolute best.

Across Rec League

All Natural Smooth Peanut Butter

“When in doubt, we Teddie. Smear it on an apple, dollop it into yogurt. Eat it off a spoon like a lollipop. Lunch is ready in 2 min 30 seconds.”

105

Jim Biancolo

“Love Teddie PB, but I don’t love when the oil dribbles over the side when I’m mixing it and the jar is then vaguely oily forever (Sensory Defensives unite!). Two recs: Store the jar upside down so when it separates the oil goes to the top (which is the bottom). When you mix it start by just stabbing the knife into the middle of the PB. Grip like Norman Bates. Slowly at first. Just stab. Just in th”

Pawan Deshpande

“Peanut butter's high oil content and the hot-filling manufacturing process significantly accelerate the leaching of fat-soluble chemical plasticizers and the shedding of microplastics directly from plastic jars into the food. Instead get Teddie Peanut Butter which comes in a glass jar with a metal cap. The cap is coated with plastics and machine closed tightly which releases microplastics, so wipe”