Sarah

Sarah Creal Mascara

$40

Recommended by Sarah
Visit

Total unlock. This one's for the peeps who like a little sticky length on their lashes but less tar near their eyeballs. It goes on smooth, and then some sort of magic occurs: it doesn't flake like other fiber mascaras, but you will be so weirded out the first time you wash your face. All the fibers slide right off.

Beauty

a month ago

Comments

Sign up to leave a comment.

Across Rec League

Back of the Cab Volumizing Longwear Tubing Mascara

Back of the Cab Volumizing Longwear Tubing Mascara
Hannah Cassidy

Hannah Cassidy

“Have been testing this for a week and damn it’s good. Fits my very specific mascara preferences: feels nonexistent, is easy as possible to remove, looks natural but is also noticeably babely. The formula reminds me of L’Oreal’s (now discontinued) Feather Lash (RIP to a legend) but has a tubing formula that doesn’t feel too much like a tubing formula (iykyk). Aka it feels like it’s nourishing my la”

3
Alex Heide

Alex Heide

“I've tried so many mascaras - this one doesn't run or flake! I love it.”

See 1 more

More like this

Aerie Nice Moves Barrel Pant

Aerie Nice Moves Barrel Pant

Timeless Vitamin C + E Ferulic

Timeless Vitamin C + E Ferulic

Bisou Balm

Bisou Balm

Miromiro in Truckee

Miromiro in Truckee

Follow Sarah

By submitting, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy

R
L
Share your recommendations on Rec League

© 2026PrivacyTerms