PaulineL

"The Case Against the Trauma Plot" by Parul Sehgal

Recommended by PaulineL
even*cleveland
Visit
Coups de CoeurStarter Pack

History

even*cleveland1d ago

Re-read this valuable essay after watching Zoe Kazan's adaptation of EAST OF EDEN. Florence Pugh was terrific, but changing Cathy's origin story to a trauma plot struck me as a massive failure of imagination. Something similar mars Marlon James' THE DISAPPEARERS, which also has a trauma plot that presents the reader with what Seghal calls "locks and keys."

19 hours ago

Comments

Sign up to leave a comment.

Across Rec League

The Case Against the Trauma Plot

The Case Against the Trauma Plot
even*cleveland

even*cleveland

“Re-read this valuable essay after watching Zoe Kazan's adaptation of EAST OF EDEN. Florence Pugh was terrific, but changing Cathy's origin story to a trauma plot struck me as a massive failure of imagination. Something similar mars Marlon James' THE DISAPPEARERS, which also has a trauma plot that presents the reader with what Seghal calls "locks and keys."”

10
See 1 more

More like this

Sunset Park Pothole Coaster

Sunset Park Pothole Coaster

Alphabetical Diaries by Sheila Heti

Alphabetical Diaries by Sheila Heti

Ali Eyal’s Tiny Sketches

Ali Eyal’s Tiny Sketches

Trinkets

Trinkets

Follow PaulineL

By submitting, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy

R
L
Share your recommendations on Rec League

© 2026PrivacyTerms