Waterproof mascara that isn’t clumpy and can hang on my perimenopausal sweaty face without slippin’?

Question

Sam · Answer

KUSH High Roll tubing mascara: I don’t want to know what unholy petrochemical makes this work so well but you will simply not catch me ripping my eyelashes out trying to remove regular waterproof mascara EVER AGAIN

Katie Russo · Answer

e.l.f Lash Xtender mascara: From one peri woman to another… This tubular formula was recommended to me by my eyelash lifter lady - super cheap (well, in Australia anyway) and so far works great!

Jes · Answer

REFY Lash Sculpt Mascara: Had a full blown panic attack/crying jag while I happened to be wearing this mascara and it DID NOT BUDGE. Wand is shaped weird and has a bit of a learning curve. I like the brown one.