Lucy Propper

69 love songs

Recommended by Lucy Propper

5 months ago

Comments

Sign up to leave a comment.

Steven Weill
@weill
Hit us with your top three of the 69
Lucy Propper
@lucypropper
Impossible question but gun2my head i think id say epitaph for my heart, papa was a rodeo, I think I need a new heart WBU?
Steven Weill
@weill
I took on the certifiably insane task of ranking them all years ago. Your three are #3, #2 & #5 respectively for me. I have Yeah! Oh, Yeah! @ #1.
Lucy Propper
@lucypropper
HELLyeah That is awesome undertaking, what was 4? Also chicken w its head cut off is up top for me
Steven Weill
@weill
I Don't Want to Get Over You @ #4. I'll have to revisit chicken, which I definitely remember being funny & fun in a country way. It made the top third of the 69 for sure but not sure how much higher than that.
Lucy Propper
@lucypropper
I don’t want to get over you is in my top 5 listened to songs ever but due to the negative emotions around when I was listening that song at an inhumane amount I skip it these days but I think soon I’ll be able to let it just play
Kathleen Jordan
@kathleenjordan
Come Back from San Francisco’s gotta creep up in that top five
Steven Weill
@weill
You need me like the wind needs the trees to blow in is an all timer lyric. I think I put it way lower than it deserved because I wanted to punish it for being popular. Love our different takes here and should prob rerank with fresh perspective soon. Or do a community based ranking???
Abby Phoenix
@aphoenix
It was an incredible show, I saw it too! I feel like 69 songs means everyone can have different favorites… that said, Papa Was a Rodeo is probably a top contender for me too. The last verse gets me every single time.
Steven Weill
@weill
Ugh yeah 100%. I really can't explain why Yeah Oh Yeah has such a hold over me otherwise Rodeo would be my #1 far and away. I'm also a sucker for the huge fast forward at the end of a story. Doesn't help that he also talks about crying 😭

Across Rec League

69 Love Songs

69 Love Songs
Maddy M

Maddy M

“Tender, funny, strange, perfect”

6
cole

cole

@coleb

6
See 1 more

Follow Lucy Propper

By submitting, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy

© 2026PrivacyTerms