Best cherry pie in NYC? Also curious about your favorite cherry pies anywhere, don’t be shy about dropping a rec even if it’s nowhere near New York :)

Question

Clara · Answer

Petee’s Pie Co.: The pie forks they give you if you’re eating in are just *chef’s kiss*

I especially adore the chocolate chess.

Sarah Cooney · Answer

Kerber's Farm: Best pies ever! They have an outpost on Bleeker but all make the trip to Huntington if you can for even more goodies. The cookbook is also phenomenal.

Sealligator · Answer

twede’s cafe: coffee’s just ok but their cherry pie really is a miracle

JV · Answer

June-July Means Cherry Pie, I Won't Blame You If You Buy: Petee's NY Sour Cherry is a very reasonable substitute, if you don't give a fuck about making a pie yourself this summer.

Loose Links · Answer

Pie Bird: Hannah is the pie queen! Her sour cherry pie is 🙌🏼✨🤤